The tragedy of the book the outliers is that it perpetuated the myth of hard work leads to success. Aug 21, 2019 the work is the latest blow to the 10,000hour rule, the idea promoted in malcolm gladwells 2008 book, outliers, which has been taken to mean that enough practice will make an expert of anyone. Gladwell uses several examples in his book when introducing this rule. And another point is that you should spend 0 hours to master any skill and become sort of pro. The story of success is the third nonfiction book written by malcolm gladwell and published by little, brown and company on november 18, 2008. Mar, 2017 gladwell did a bait and switch, in his book first ignoring the role of talent, and then when pressed for more details, clarifying that the 10,000 hour rule applies to those who already have talent but then practiced 10,00 hours to hone such talent. A myth is a false belief or idea that is widely held. The idea has become really entrenched in our culture.
Anders ericsson, the florida state university psychologist whose research spawned the 10,000 hour rule of thumb it takes roughly 10,000 hours of study and work at a particular thing to become an expert at. Their research included 111 independent samples, with 157 effect sizes and a total sample of 11,5 participants 5. When psychologists talk about deliberate practice, they mean practicing in a way that. The 10,000 hour rule is not real smithsonian magazine.
One such myth that has enveloped youth sports is the idea that to become an elite athlete all one needs 10,000 hours of sustained, deliberate training. Indeed, a wellestablished piece of lore, popularly known as the 10,000 hour rule, states that to be an expert in any domain, you need to have practiced it for at least 10,000 hours. The 10,000hour rule for sporting success is largely a. Ericssons studies support that experts typically spend more than 10,000 hours perfecting their art, practice must be regular, intentional, and guided by an existing expert. The study was originally done by a scientist named anders ericsson, and has been quoted in almost every skills development context you continued. To support his thesis, he examines why the majority of canadian ice hockey players are born in the first. Gladwell says that research has even settled on the magic number of hours it takes to achieve expertise. The work is the latest blow to the 10,000hour rule, the idea promoted in malcolm gladwells 2008 book, outliers, which has been taken to mean. The myth of the 10,000hours rule is why we need coaches. To make her point, she noted the oftcited notion that one has to put in 10,000 hours of practice to be considered an expert or a master in their field. While even though the 10,000 hour rule seems too good to be true, because it is, this wont stop many people from still trying to achieve this goal. The 10,000hour rule that this level of practice holds the secret to great success in any field has become sacrosanct gospel, echoed on. Lets start with breaking down the myth of the 10,000 hour rule.
Gladwell did a bait and switch, in his book first ignoring the role of talent, and then when pressed for more details, clarifying that the 10,000 hour rule applies to those who already have talent but then practiced 10,00 hours. What it actually takes to reach geniuslevel excellence by maria popova, whose brain pickings is one of my favorite sites. The 10,000 hour rulefirst proposed by a swedish psychologist and later made famous in malcolm gladwells outliers states that exceptional expertise requires at least 10,000 hours of. The 10,000hour rule about being an expert is wrong.
Ten thousand hours is the magic number of greatness, gladwell. Now, to the myth of 10,000 hours and something ive gleaned from the book i mention aboveand the bigger point of this memo. In the 10,000 hour book, goleman debunks the 10,000 hour rule mythology to reveal the more complex truth behind reaching success. In the chapter the 10,000hour rule by malcolm gladwell, he argues that the amount of practice required for the mastery of anything is 10,000 hours.
This 10,000 hours of practice rule is based on research by psychologist anders ericsson, now at florida state university. Does 10,000 hour rule mentioned in outliers 2008 book. Its a common rule of thumb, popularized by malcom gladwell in his bestseller outliers. He had been composing concertos for ten years by this time. I recently gave a talk at a national soccer coaches meeting. The principle holds that 10,000 hours of deliberate practice are needed to become worldclass in any field. Dec 15, 2018 the 10,000hour rule is a popular ideology that when you put 10,000 hours practicing deliberately on an activity you can master it.
An urban myth has developed that their paper says you can master something simply by doing it for 10,000 hours. Anders ericsson, who studied the way people become experts in their fields. The 10,000hour rule is wrong and perpetuates a cruel myth 217. You dont need to walk 10,000 steps every day the atlantic. He uses examples of famous people or groups of people that the audience might know to try and dispel the myth that to be able to master something, it takes more than innate talent. The 10,000hour rule is wrong and perpetuates a cruel myth. Oct 16, 2019 scientists debunk the myth that 10,000 hours of practice makes you an expert can a magic number define your expertise or really make you an expert at anything.
The idea was then popularized in the book outliers by journalist malcolm gladwell. Apr 04, 20 the myth of the 10,000 hours rule posted on april 4, 20 by hayim makabee following the outliers book by malcom gladwell, some people are convinced that if they just invest 10,000 hours in something they will become really good at it. The elite had more than double the practice hours of the less capable performers. After reading this book you realise that that anyone is capable of achieving just about anything and that those geniuses we have all been so in awe of are just humans who have put in a whole load of hard damned work. You become what you practice by lane, phyllis, coelho, rodrigo, lane, phyllis, lane, phyllis isbn. In reality, this isnt always the case, yet effort is a major factor in how well we do in the tasks we choose or are given. Gladwell claims that greatness requires enormous time, using the source of the beatles musical talents and gates computer savvy as examples. Apr, 2016 the only thing i knew about malcolm gladwells book outliers, was that this is the book that the 10,000 hour rule came from. A 1993 psychology paper, by the psychologist anders ericsson of the florida state university, first introduced this widely touted idea that 10,000 hours of practice can make you an.
Aug 20, 2014 the 10,000 hour rulefirst proposed by a swedish psychologist and later made famous in malcolm gladwells outliersstates that exceptional expertise requires at least 10,000 hours of practice. The myth of 10,000 hours no, you cant become an expert after 10,000 hours of practice often, as children, we are encouraged to believe that if we work hard then well succeed. Scientists debunk the myth that 10,000 hours of practice makes you an expert can a magic number define your expertise or really make you an expert at anything. Over the past decade, everyone seems to have heard of the socalled 10,000hour rule, popularized by malcolm gladwell in his book outliers. Ericssons research found that many of the most advanced violin students at a large music academy had put in approximately 10,000 hours of practice to achieve their level of excellence. And this holds true even for those select few we consider prodigies. It is a mustread if you have ever wondered what sets the superachievers and the rest of us apart in any field, not just in sport.
A common theme that appears throughout outliers is the 10,000hour rule, based on a study by anders ericsson. Scientists debunk the myth that 10,000 hours of practice. Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. The 10,000hour rule was wrong, according to the people who. This rule was coined by malcolm gladwell in his book outliers in 2008. The 10,000 hours rule is a myththe person whos most miffed by it is the guy whose research its based on. Of course 10k hours doesnt guarantee mastery either. As well as the 10,000 hour myth the media coverage of the road to success for tiger woods in golf and. The rule was made famous by malcolm gladwells book the outliers. Dec 31, 2017 in his 2008 book outliers, malcolm gladwell argues that success is tightly married to opportunity and time on task. I havent read the book, but what i heard about it second hand is that 10k hours is about mastery, not success. The hidden driver of excellence, which is next on my to read stack.
Then i read debunking the myth of the 10,000hours rule. Its so tragic because malcolm gladwell works so hard to establish. Malcolm gladwell the 10 000 hour rule rhetorical devices. The 10,000hour rule for sporting success is largely a myth. The hidden driver of excellencepublic library, celebrated psychologist and journalist daniel goleman, bestknown for his influential 1995 book emotional intelligence, debunks the 10,000hour mythology to reveal the more complex truth beneath the popular rule of thumb. Blow to 0hour rule as study finds practice doesnt always make. Photography for real estate the myth of 10,000 hours. The 10,000hour rule is compelling in a world that clings to the idea that people rise up through society based on merit.
One of his key points is the prevailing belief that you must spend 10,000 hours practicing a skill to become good at it. As you can see by the title, goleman deconstructs the myth of 10,000 hours. Jul, 2012 the expert myth or, three books versus 10,000 hours. For gladwell, it meant correctly practicing a skill for around 10,000 hours in order to arrive at an expertise thats considered to be worldclass. Throughout the book, gladwell used the 10,000hour rule as the key to achieve success. You can be a master without being successful and visa versa.
Jul 16, 2017 when i read malcolm gladwells book, outliers, many years ago, where he says you need approximately 10,000 hours of purposeful and deliberate practice to master something it made a bit of sense, although i thought it was clearly a gross simplifica. The hidden driver of excellence public library, celebrated psychologist and journalist daniel goleman, bestknown for his influential 1995 book emotional intelligence, debunks the 10,000hour mythology to reveal the more complex truth beneath the popular rule of thumb. Throughout the publication, gladwell repeatedly mentions the 10,000hour rule, claiming that the key to achieving worldclass expertise in any skill, is, to a. Mar 02, 2020 throughout the book, gladwell used the 10,000hour rule as the key to achieve success. The 10,000hour rule that this level of practice holds the secret to great success in any field has become sacrosanct gospel, echoed on websites and recited as litany in highperformance workshops. If many of the persistent myths of american health, like eating breakfast. Malcolm gladwells 0 hours rule explained more than. Was the 0 hour rule of mastery finally exposed as an urban myth. This deliberate practice goes beyond simple repetition and adjustment to diagnose problem areas.
Carving out 10,000 hours of practice in childhood requires the support of the adults in your life. The only thing i knew about malcolm gladwells book outliers, was that this is the book that the 10,000 hour rule came from. Most people have heard the meme that to become an expert in a particular field, you need to do 10,000 hours worth of practice. The rule tells us, a mere 10,000 hours of dedicated practice in your. Their research is really a great study trying to test the widespread 10,000hour rule popularized in a number of books e. In his 2008 book outliers, malcolm gladwell argues that success is tightly married to opportunity and time on task. Most people never got to the final page and the tragedy of this book is that it perpetuated the myth of the 10,000 hour rule. The 10,000hour rule for sporting success is largely a myth, so let.
Blow to 10,000hour rule as study finds practice doesnt always. Books such as outliers by malcolm gladwell and bounce by matthew syed. The 10,000hour rule about being an expert is wrong heres why. The 10,000hour rule was debunked again in a replication study.
Beyond the 10,000 hour myth how we really acquire skill. These circumstances often emerge from two external factors. The 10,000hour rule for sporting success is largely a myth, so let kids dabble. Aug 23, 2019 the 10,000hour rule is compelling in a world that clings to the idea that people rise up through society based on merit. The 10,000hour rule was debunked again in a replication. That 10,000hour rule has wormed its way into popular. May 27, 2019 the 10,000hour rule for sporting success is largely a myth, so let kids dabble. In recent years, one of the most persistent poppsychology claims has been the myth of the 10,000hour rule the idea that this is the amount of time one must invest in practice in order to reach meaningful success in any field. The widely touted theory, highlighted in a 1993 psychology paper and popularized by malcolm gladwells book outliers, says that anyone can master a skill with 10,000 hours of practice. By age twenty, the elite performers averaged more than 10,000 hours of practice each, while the less able performers had only 4,000 hours of practice. The expert myth or, three books versus 10,000 hours oh to be home again, in old virginny what constitutes expertise, whether its photography or anything else in life. In outliers, gladwell examines the factors that contribute to high levels of success. The expert myth or, three books versus 10,000 hours.
It is a concept that was made popular by malcom gladwell, in his book, outliers. This 10,000 hours of practice rule is based on research by psychologist anders. The expert myth or, three books versus 10,000 hours just. Gladwell never says that it takes 10,000 hours to become really good or an expert, he simply implies that 10,000 hours of practice results in what we would consider a genius or master i. The story of success, in which he cites the work of anders ericsson. As outliers became popular, so did the principle of the 10,000hour rule. Mar 11, 2016 in his book gladwell expresses the concept of 10,000 hours in a number of ways. The study found that the most accomplished of the students had put in 10,000 hours by the time they turned 20.
He states that it takes approximately 10,000 hours to master something. It is not simply 10,000 hours that makes us an expert at something, he says. However, what many parents are unaware of is that this rule has later been discredited on many counts and the original man behind the research anders ericsson has publicly bemoaned the context that gladwell used it in his book outliers. However, at age eight, practice times began to diverge. If you put 10,000 hours of practice into something, you can become an expert right. In the book, gladwell states that ten thousand hours is the magic number of greatness.
Over the past decade, everyone seems to have heard of the socalled 10,000 hour rule, popularized by malcolm gladwell in his book outliers. Anders ericsson, a psychologist and later on, popularized by malcolm gladwell in his book entitled outliers, the 10,000hour rule argues that anyone can be an expert. This idea is encapsulated in a golden rule made popular by the writer malcolm gladwell in his book outliers. By the time mozart composed his first masterwork he was 21. Mar 01, 2019 if there is an urban myth aspect, it is because people dont read well. The 10,000 hour rule is not real smart news smithsonian. You need to be in pretty extraordinary circumstances with the extraordinary opportunities they provide to accumulate 10,000 hours of focused practice as a young person. The 10,000hour rule was invented by malcolm gladwell who stated that, researchers have settled on what they believe is the magic number for true expertise.
Jun 09, 2016 creativity the 10,000hour rule was wrong, according to the people who wrote the original study what is really required to become an expert is very different. Books such as outliers by malcolm gladwell and bounce by matthew syed have reinforced this idea by propagating the 10,000hour rule for. Scientists debunk the myth that 10,000 hours of practice makes you an expert a theory malcolm gladwell popularized in outliers that 10,000 hours of practice can turn anyone into an expert. Why the 10,000 hour rule is a myth the following is an excerpt from daniel golemans new book, focus. Most people never finished the book and its evident because if they had the 10,000 hour rule would not have become such a legend. Apr 19, 2010 owen slot chief sports reporter, the times i love this book. The myth of the 10,000 hours rule posted on april 4, 20 by hayim makabee following the outliers book by malcom gladwell, some people are convinced that if they just invest 10,000 hours in something they will become really good at it. Take at least 10,000 steps a day, which is about five miles of walking for most people. Anders ericsson, a psychologist and later on, popularized by malcolm gladwell in his book entitled outliers, the 10,000hour rule argues that anyone can be an expert of various fields by allotting thousands of hours to become successful in it. The concept of the 10,000hour rule is derived from the work of psychologist k. Ive put in that much on the golf course, and i still suck at it. This question was originally answered on quora by robert frost.
77 1118 1365 612 1400 528 1071 1392 848 1346 577 56 668 706 353 1372 21 199 637 283 230 767 64 218 946 927 262 786 1315 701 212 463 843 437 504 725 359 941 1478 913 630